Nar is speaker as far as i can see, and without a definite female ending it makes the name masculine.
We definitely need a language expert on the board...
Sounds good to me.Certainly, nar/nari could work like tar/tari, and I will suggest Quennari as an alternative to Quennar.
And we have Diriel. Any other suggestions?
Any other remarks?
I have some problems with the concept of a small Idril. We’ve cast taller actors/actresses for both her parents (Turgon’s actor is 6’5” and Gabrielle Wilde is 5’10”), so the odds are on her being relatively tall and being short will make her look like she’s not their daughter. A smaller Idril will undoubtedly struggle in kissing scenes with Tuor (I witnessed this sort of thing with Sally Hawkins, who was 5’2”, and Rupert Penry-Jones (6’2”) in Persuasion). Furthermore, Elves on principle are tall, so Idril will not look like an Elf.
So basically, we made Galathil a woman?Celeborn’s sibling - sister who is Green-elf spokesperson and still there in Third Age frame, Nimloth is her daughter
I don’t think we decided on a name.So basically, we made Galathil a woman?
So I gather but I meant that we’ve invented a female elf, the sister of Celeborn, whose daughter is Nimloth. We have chosen not to include (as far as I have understood) Galathil, who is the brother of Celeborn, supposedly the father of Nimloth. So we’ve made a gender switch, basically.I don’t think we decided on a name.
Did we directly include Galathil on the list?So I gather but I meant that we’ve invented a female elf, the sister of Celeborn, whose daughter is Nimloth. We have chosen not to include (as far as I have understood) Galathil, who is the brother of Celeborn, supposedly the father of Nimloth. So we’ve made a gender switch, basically.
@Faelivrin won’t like this, especially since Nimloth’s mother won’t play a part in the upbringing of her descendants like Elrond and Elros. It also makes her a bit... neglectful.So I gather but I meant that we’ve invented a female elf, the sister of Celeborn, whose daughter is Nimloth. We have chosen not to include (as far as I have understood) Galathil, who is the brother of Celeborn, supposedly the father of Nimloth. So we’ve made a gender switch, basically.