Recent content by HowthCE

  1. HowthCE

    The Problem with Boromir's Argument

    Thanks for the discussion, everyone! At this point, I don't think we have any reason to believe the motives of the people in the room are anything but pure. Rather, I'm working on the assumption that the ring has volition and is recommending itself to anyone who will listen. We're not yet...
  2. HowthCE

    The Problem with Boromir's Argument

    Hello! I want to push back a little on the notion that Boromir's argument was a good one. While it may seem logical to use the enemy's weapon against him, we (and Boromir) have already been given the tools to disqualify Boromir's argument within this very council. For starters, Gandalf has...
Back
Top