amysrevenge
Well-Known Member
This is prompted by the discussion of the script for S4Ep3, but would be off topic there so I'm doing it here.
I have a question that I feel like we need to answer, and will need to continually re-visit and re-answer as future seasons go on and on and on.
Cirdan wants to re-unite with the Teleri.
He has the means to do so at any time, and at least as far as he knows he has permission (or rather he doesn't really know that "persmission" is even an issue). It's not until later that they know that the road West is closed for the rest of the 1st Age, but it does re-open in the 2nd Age.
He doesn't do it.
Why?
I have a question that I feel like we need to answer, and will need to continually re-visit and re-answer as future seasons go on and on and on.
Cirdan wants to re-unite with the Teleri.
He has the means to do so at any time, and at least as far as he knows he has permission (or rather he doesn't really know that "persmission" is even an issue). It's not until later that they know that the road West is closed for the rest of the 1st Age, but it does re-open in the 2nd Age.
He doesn't do it.
Why?