I'm starting to think that would be a problem. Especially if we want to leave open the possibility of killing one of the twins at the Shipburning. Killing someone who looks like a young teenager would be very different than killing a young, but full grown, man. His reasons for still being on the Ship, too, would inescapably look different. It would be really easy for it to look immature/rash/petulant, which I don't think any of us want.One thing I'm not so happy with is that Berdy looks very much younger. What do you think, is that a problem or actually something good?
I think I prefer Booth as Celegorm.
Yeah... I think they can look the part, but, if we cast Efron, I'd suggest he'd been the twin we kill off (if we kill one off).Efron's not that great. Don't know anything about Zegers
So what do you think about this one? I must confess I didn't see The Borgias.Or this guy, who also played in The Borgias. he could work. Probably better as Caranthir.
View attachment 1057View attachment 1058
Francois Arnaud.
I'm in favor of it, obviously, but we won't really know until we get into the individual episodes outline sessions. I'm thinking the Shipburning will probably happen about midseason (?), so... if we don't take any breaks between seasons, we should decide that around... the end of July?So will we kill one off early?
Well, that goes for most of the project, I guess...This seems to be the sort of thing he likes to have the final word about.
Yes, it's later. I think from around the same time as the Andreth/Finrod debate?It was someting Tolien wrote late in life, right? And he didn't incorporate it into the stories that follow? I think that's why Christopher Tolkien chose not to include it in the PubSil. I can't remember what Dr O has said about this, if he's expressed a clear opinion. This seems to be the sort of thing he likes to have the final word about.