Indeed... and when it so neatly fills in all those holes and gaps in the "official story"...Haha the best lie is 99% truth. The more we talk about this for Sauron, the more I looove it.
Last edited:
Indeed... and when it so neatly fills in all those holes and gaps in the "official story"...Haha the best lie is 99% truth. The more we talk about this for Sauron, the more I looove it.
My thought was that they would be nameless characters and do a lot of listening, unless we have a known character or two that Sauron and Thuringwethil kill to impersonate.I think that a number of Sindar could have arrived before the feast to help add to decorations and preparations? They’d be servants or similar and move around doing stuff the Noldor nobles won’t really bother about. One or two artisans could be Sauron and Thuringwethil. Would we have to use subtitles for such situations? In any case, before the feast, the Noldor will not be as cautious as when the Sindar guests have arrived.
Or would they act as known characters?
Where are the Noldor stationed up to the Mereth Aderthad?
Maybe it's an Elf-y mind-meld/what we may call magic. An uncontrolled or unintentional two-way telepathy.
So they judge that the safest thing is just not discuss anything that happened in Valinor?Apparently, they are not mentioning the death of Finwë in their initial story....which suggests that there *is* no actual story about what happened over there beyond them refusing to speak of it.
Yes this was my point, thank you.Círdan hears rumors that point to Olwë's death. He concludes that the burned ships he saw were stolen by the Noldor, and reports his suspicions to Thingol.
Ah thank you, I was messing things up... The point would be to have Sauron act as someone people around him don’t know and belonging to a group that some Noldoli nobles don’t know very well, som that two conditions are met: people could feel free to talk (but of course not too freely), while not actually knowing that they’re not overheard by someone who shouldn’t hear. I’m also a bit reluctant to have them listening during the party; what would be said about the Kinslaying during the feast?@Haakon , do you mean Noldorin servants from Nevrast?
By before or after the Feast, I actually was asking about other episodes. Not that there’s anything wrong with your idea.
I’m also a bit reluctant to have them listening during the party; what would be said about the Kinslaying during the feast?