Liam Neeson, obviously. 
Mythgard Forums
Nicholas Palazzo
Nicholas Palazzo
Though on a more serious note, we do need a mature man who is both active and gentle.
Alex Long
HOW IN THE WORLD DID WE FORGET THIS!?!?!
Alex Long
Let's get Stuart Townsend to do it since he never got the chance to play Aragorn. It can be a meta-casting.