Recent content by Haerangil

  1. Haerangil

    the cold empty void beneath Tolkien's romantic ideal

    Within the range, yes, but such elves often go fey and become insame, suffering of deadly depression. So far i am missing the joy with Arwen. I can see she wpuld have many sad moments, it lies in the burden of being the last of her kind, but ONLY sadness? I feel it ruins the end of the lord of...
  2. Haerangil

    the cold empty void beneath Tolkien's romantic ideal

    It is an interestingbstory, but not the kind of sadness i enjoy reading. Yet i agree Tolkien wrote a number of beautiful but very sad stories. Arwen is the Evenstar... the end of her her people, but i don't likebthe idea of such a sad end and of Arwen as such a sad person.If thete is such...
  3. Haerangil

    the cold empty void beneath Tolkien's romantic ideal

    This is so sad... but the story of Arwen's end is sad.
  4. Haerangil

    Uruk-hai

    "Hai" might be a corruption of elvish "waith", "people". They're an oddity, the only sub-breed of orc we know by name, and Jrrt is a bit contradictive on their exact character and origin, maybe intentionally and he likes us riddling about them. High elves and high men became "higher" due to...
  5. Haerangil

    The Long Winter - a Middle Earth rpg?

    If you like, i'm certainly curious.
  6. Haerangil

    The Long Winter - a Middle Earth rpg?

    Sounds nice ,i once also created my own, very simplified rpg system intended for improvising short adventures... at the moment i am trying out AI rpg, i fed it with data about eastern middle-earth and now its simulating young aragorns adventures in rhûn for me... quite nice.
  7. Haerangil

    Cast So Far...

    Huh? Watanabe as Saruman? Seriously? You vetoed casting Asians or black people as Avari elves because that might look racist but now we cast an asian actor as Saruman? Look... i know this is just a fanfic project, it isn't real, but i don't have to understand your decisions guys... mind we...
  8. Haerangil

    Season 1 Script Outlines

    I remember most episodes just being outlines or even just collected notes FOR outlines. There are several finished scripts... but the board had always trouble making them easily attainable, don't know why.I always had to do lots of searching and scrolling to get to them... a bit unnerving, i...
  9. Haerangil

    When might the Dwarves of Khazad-dum started to become "too greedy"?

    Mind the ring was made to preserve and maybe given by Celebrimbor in that intention.
  10. Haerangil

    Script Discussion: S07E08

    We use reincarnation instead returning from the grave ,yet father and son use the same names. What's the point then of using reincarnation as well as the returning actor? Doesn't make any sense concept-wise. I suppose we decided against returning from the grave to avoid confusion, yet now father...
  11. Haerangil

    Script Discussion: S07E08

    That not EVERY dwarf king is one of the Seven is crystal clear! But the rest makes no sense to me at all.
  12. Haerangil

    Script Discussion: S07E08

    Now i am even more confused. Are the dwarf-fathers reborn or rejuvenated? Is Azaghal one of the seven? I thought so far Azaghal and Laurin always have been played by the same actor... do they reincarnate or return re-envigoured? You now sound as if they are born like normal dwarves and only...
  13. Haerangil

    Script Discussion: S07E08

    Didn't Azaghal return from the grave rejuvenated, like Durin? So... he has brothers?
  14. Haerangil

    Script Discussion: S07E08

    I still like some alliteration or similarity... Sincin and Doldrin, Mîr and Doldir, Sabir and Gondir, Gerin and Beglin, Tars and Tagron, Drabir and Drauthir... though i kinda like Fam and Naurfing too...
Back
Top