- I nominate Liam Hemsworth. he has a nice, good guy look, which works well for Eonwë, and the viewers will be crushed when he is killed on his first real mission.
- Young, strapping
- Slender but broad shouldered
- "18"... Well, he's 26 but he could play 18, Hollywood does that all the time.
- Can easily go from boyish to young manly knight.
- Look a bit like Manwë (well, if we cast Daniel Day-Lewis, they've got the eyebrows...)
EDIT: WAS CHOSEN; OK BY EXECS