I think Dr Olsen said he didn't really want to go that far. But still, I like your idea. For Lúthien especially.I think that both Arwen and Luthien should look a bit like a young Edith Tolkien:
![]()
We must try to find an actress who looks like Edith when we do the casting for Lúthien. But I maintain that Arwen should be played by another actress. And I think it will be hard to find one actress who is an Edith look alike, and extremely hard to find two such actresses. Let's try to think of Arwen as someone who reminds people of Lúthien, but in a more subtle way.