No they weren't great heroes like Turin, Tuor or Hador, but they were still close relatives and people that Elros and Elrond would have probably liked to meet.That wasn't what I meant. I meant that they probably weren't prominent famous heroes who everyone in Beleriand had heard of. They don't even get names.
He was a Numenorean noble, who would later marry Aldarion's sister.I did not remember this person. Can you please point me to where they are described or named? I thought Orchaldor was the nickname or title of Galdor. In any case, I thought there was a statement somewhere that Elrond and Elros were the only descendants of the heroic chieftains of the Edain. I wish I could remember where I read it.
Why? The Sindar were a lot more loyal to Elwe than the Noldor were to Fingolfin. The people of the Havens had no problem with Earendil being their leader. We don't even know for sure if the Noldor did pick the eldest royal, in Tolkien's latest ideas it seems they used Salic Law. The Noldor also don't seem to have even had kings through the female line, whilst the Sindar obviously did.Because Elmo, Galadhon, and Celeborn were all millennia older than Dior. If they were alive they would be more likely to be kings than Dior, who was very young. It seems to me the Sindar would have picked the eldest royal, like the Noldor did.
Dior took the name as Elwe's heir and I see no reason, why the Elves that love Thingol the most would not accept his heir. Even more so when he is the grandson of Melian and the son of Luthien, who is the greatest and most beloved of all the Elves
I can't find the quote so perhaps I just imagined it, but it makes a lot of sense for the exiled Noldor to be forbidden from taking part. The Sindar might have been allowed to fight, but the Valar may have wanted to make it perfectly clear the exiles completely failed. It makes perfect sense for them to emphasis the Fall or Morgoth had nothing to do with the rebellion.I don't see that Tolkien said they were forbidden. Eonwe summoned all the Elves and Men to his banner. Why would he summon them, but make a law banning them from doing anything?
The reason the exiles might have been excluded is that the Valar wanted to draw a line between the rebellion and what was going on now.I don't think Elrond and Elros did nothing. I don't think Maedhros and Maglor were doing nothing. I don't think anyone chose to hide and do absolutely nothing during the War of Wrath, because why would anyone want to do that? They were not cowards or pacifists. I think Gil-galad, the Feanorians, the Sindar, the Edain, the Exiles, and the Dwarves were all fighting against Morgoth's hordes. I can't see any reason why any of them would refuse to participate. They hate Morgoth, and finally have hope of his defeat.
It's not a case of them refusing to try, but not being allowed to. They had tried things by themselves and utterly failed. Now the Valar were showing what they could do.The Exiles need not be effective or accomplish anything significant in the War. They certainly don't have many forces left. I don't think that's a reason to make them refuse to even try.